Is grain-free dog food really healthier, or are ancient grains the secret to canine nutrition? With so much conflicting information flooding pet parent forums and social media, choosing natural dog food for your furry companion can feel overwhelming.
The pet food industry has seen dramatic shifts in recent years. Following the FDA's 2019 investigation into potential links between grain-free diets and heart disease in dogs, many pet parents found themselves questioning their food choices. Meanwhile, ancient grains have emerged as a promising middle ground—offering the benefits of whole food nutrition without the controversy surrounding grain-free formulas.
Here's the truth: premium dog food quality matters far more than following trends. Whether grain-free or grain-inclusive, what your dog needs is high-quality, natural ingredients that support their individual health needs.
At Talis-us, we've curated this comprehensive guide to help you navigate the grain-free versus ancient grains debate with confidence. Backed by veterinary research and our stringent quality standards, this guide will help you make the best nutrition choice for your dog's unique needs.
What Makes Dog Food "Natural"?
Before diving into the grain debate, let's establish what "natural" actually means in the pet food world—because not all products labeled "natural" are created equal.
AAFCO Definition of Natural Pet Food
According to the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO), natural pet food is defined as a feed or ingredient derived solely from plant, animal, or mined sources. This means:
-
No chemically synthesized ingredients (with the exception of vitamins, minerals, and trace nutrients)
-
Minimal processing that doesn't fundamentally alter the raw ingredient
-
No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives
However, the AAFCO definition is just the starting point. Many commercial foods meet this basic standard while still containing low-quality fillers, unnamed meat by-products, or excessive processing.
Beyond the Label: Talis-Us Quality Standards
At Talis-us, our natural dog food collection goes beyond minimum standards. Every product in our curated selection meets these rigorous criteria:
Limited-Ingredient Formulations: Fewer ingredients mean easier identification of potential allergens and better digestibility. We feature foods with clean, recognizable ingredient lists—no mysterious "meat meal" or vague protein sources.
Single-Protein Options: For dogs with sensitivities or allergies, single-protein formulas (like pure turkey, salmon, or lamb) eliminate the guesswork and reduce reaction risk.
Vet-Recommended Brands: Our "Vet-Recommended" badge appears only on brands that veterinary nutritionists consistently endorse based on ingredient quality, research backing, and manufacturing standards.
No Artificial Additives: Zero artificial preservatives (like BHA, BHT, or ethoxyquin), synthetic colors, or artificial flavors. Natural preservation methods like mixed tocopherols (vitamin E) and vitamin C are acceptable.
Transparent Sourcing: Brands must disclose protein sources and manufacturing locations. "Chicken" means real chicken, not chicken by-product meal from unknown origins.
When you shop natural dog food at Talis-us, you're not just buying a bag with a "natural" label—you're investing in premium nutrition that's been thoroughly vetted by our team of multi-species experts.
Understanding Grain-Free Dog Food
Grain-free dog food has dominated pet store shelves and online searches for the past decade. But what exactly does "grain-free" mean, and is it the right choice for your dog?
What Does Grain-Free Actually Mean?
Grain-free dog food formulas eliminate all traditional cereal grains, including:
-
Wheat
-
Corn
-
Rice (white and brown)
-
Oats
-
Barley
-
Rye
Instead, grain-free formulas use alternative carbohydrate sources such as:
-
Sweet potatoes
-
Peas and pea starch
-
Lentils
-
Chickpeas (garbanzo beans)
-
Tapioca
-
White potatoes
These alternative carbs provide energy while keeping the formula grain-free. Many grain-free foods also feature higher protein content from meat, fish, or poultry to compensate for the reduced carbohydrate percentage.
Benefits of Grain-Free Formulas
When formulated properly, grain-free dog food offers several legitimate benefits:
Ideal for True Grain Allergies: While genuine grain allergies are relatively rare in dogs (accounting for only about 10% of all food allergies), they do exist. Dogs with confirmed grain sensitivities experience dramatic improvements when switching to grain-free formulas. Symptoms like chronic itching, hot spots, ear infections, and digestive upset often resolve within weeks.
Lower Glycemic Index Options: Many grain-free formulas using sweet potatoes or legumes have a lower glycemic index than grain-inclusive foods relying on white rice or corn. This slower carbohydrate digestion can benefit dogs with diabetes, weight management needs, or insulin sensitivity.
Higher Protein Content: Because grain-free recipes often replace grain calories with meat-based protein, many formulas contain 30-40% protein compared to 22-26% in grain-inclusive foods. Active dogs, working breeds, and dogs with higher protein requirements thrive on these meat-forward formulas.
Reduced Digestive Issues in Sensitive Dogs: Some dogs simply digest legumes and tubers better than grains, even without a clinical allergy. If your dog has persistent soft stools, gas, or bloating on grain-inclusive foods (after ruling out other causes), grain-free may offer relief.
The DCM Controversy: What Pet Parents Need to Know
In July 2018, the FDA announced it was investigating a potential connection between grain-free diets and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM)—a serious heart condition that weakens the heart muscle and reduces pumping efficiency.
Here's what you need to know:
The Investigation Summary: The FDA identified over 500 cases of DCM in dogs eating grain-free, legume-heavy diets between 2014 and 2019. Notably, many affected dogs were breeds not typically predisposed to genetic DCM (like Golden Retrievers, Labrador Retrievers, and mixed breeds).
Current Scientific Understanding: As of 2026, research suggests the issue isn't grain-free diets themselves, but rather specific formulation factors:
-
High levels of peas, lentils, and legume-derived ingredients (pea protein, pea starch)
-
Potatoes as a primary ingredient
-
Boutique brands with limited nutritional research backing
-
Possible nutrient deficiencies (taurine, L-carnitine) in certain formulas
Risk Factors to Consider:
-
Breed predisposition: Golden Retrievers, Cocker Spaniels, Dobermans, and Irish Wolfhounds show higher risk
-
Diets where peas/lentils appear in the first 5-10 ingredients
-
Lack of taurine supplementation in high-risk formulas
-
Extended feeding duration (years on the same formula)
Expert Consensus: The American Veterinary Medical Association and board-certified veterinary nutritionists agree that not all grain-free foods pose DCM risk. Well-formulated grain-free diets from reputable manufacturers with taurine supplementation and balanced amino acid profiles can be safe and nutritious.
When Grain-Free Makes Sense
Grain-free dog food is the right choice when:
Diagnosed Grain Allergy: Your veterinarian has confirmed (through elimination diet or allergy testing) that your dog reacts to specific grains. In these cases, grain-free isn't optional—it's medical management.
Chronic Digestive Issues: After working with your vet to rule out parasites, inflammatory bowel disease, pancreatitis, and other conditions, your dog continues experiencing soft stools, vomiting, or digestive upset on grain-inclusive diets.
High-Performance Dogs: Working dogs, sporting breeds, and highly active dogs often benefit from the increased protein density and fat content in premium grain-free formulas.
Owner Preference with Precautions: If you prefer grain-free but your dog isn't at high DCM risk, choose formulas that:
-
Limit peas/lentils to small amounts
-
Include taurine supplementation
-
Come from established brands with feeding trial data
-
Use sweet potatoes or tapioca as primary carb sources
At Talis-us, our grain-free collection features only brands that meet strict formulation standards, include heart-health support, and come from manufacturers with transparent research backing.
The Case for Ancient Grains in Dog Food
While the grain-free movement captured headlines, ancient grains have quietly become veterinarians' preferred recommendation for many dogs—especially in the wake of DCM concerns.
What Are Ancient Grains?
Ancient grains are grain varieties that have remained largely unchanged by modern agricultural breeding and genetic modification. Unlike heavily hybridized wheat and corn, ancient grains retain their original nutrient profiles.
Common ancient grains in premium dog food include:
-
Quinoa: A complete protein containing all nine essential amino acids
-
Millet: Easily digestible, naturally gluten-free grain rich in B vitamins
-
Sorghum: High in antioxidants and fiber, gentle on digestion
-
Amaranth: Protein-rich, high in lysine (often deficient in grains)
-
Barley: Soluble fiber powerhouse supporting gut health
-
Oats: Rich in beta-glucans for immune system support
These grains provide complex carbohydrates, fiber, vitamins, and minerals that legume-based alternatives simply can't match.
Nutritional Benefits of Ancient Grains
Ancient grain dog foods offer impressive nutritional advantages:
Superior Fiber for Digestive Health: Ancient grains contain both soluble and insoluble fiber that supports healthy gut bacteria, regulates bowel movements, and promotes optimal digestion. Barley and oats, in particular, contain beta-glucans that feed beneficial gut microbiota.
Complex Carbohydrates for Sustained Energy: Unlike simple carbs that spike blood sugar, ancient grains provide slow-release energy. This steady glucose supply benefits dogs with diabetes, seniors with reduced activity, and puppies needing consistent energy throughout the day.
Rich Micronutrient Profile: Ancient grains deliver B vitamins (thiamine, niacin, riboflavin), minerals (magnesium, iron, zinc), and antioxidants that support everything from coat health to immune function. Quinoa alone provides manganese, magnesium, phosphorus, folate, and copper.
Naturally Gluten-Free Options: For the small percentage of dogs with wheat gluten sensitivity (different from grain allergy), ancient grains like millet, quinoa, and sorghum provide grain-based nutrition without triggering reactions.
Better Nutrient Bioavailability: Studies show that the vitamins and minerals in ancient grains are more bioavailable (easier for dogs to absorb and use) than synthetic supplements or nutrients from legumes and potatoes.
Why Vets Are Recommending Ancient Grains
Veterinary nutritionists increasingly recommend ancient grain formulas for several compelling reasons:
Addresses DCM Concerns: Ancient grain formulas provide carbohydrates without relying heavily on peas, lentils, or potatoes—the ingredients most closely associated with diet-related DCM. They naturally supply nutrients that support heart muscle function.
Supports Heart Health: Ancient grains provide amino acid precursors for taurine production, along with L-carnitine, B vitamins, and minerals that support cardiovascular function. For breeds at genetic risk for DCM (Golden Retrievers, Doberman Pinschers, Boxers), this nutritional profile offers protective benefits.
Balanced Macronutrient Ratios: Ancient grain formulas typically contain 22-28% protein, 12-16% fat, and 3-5% fiber—ratios that match ancestral canine diets more closely than extreme high-protein, low-carb formulas.
Digestive Stability: The fiber matrix in ancient grains promotes consistent, healthy stools. Veterinarians report fewer cases of chronic diarrhea, gas, and digestive upset in dogs eating ancient grain versus legume-heavy grain-free formulas.
Life-Stage Versatility: Ancient grain formulas work beautifully across life stages—from puppies needing steady energy for growth to seniors requiring gentle, fiber-rich nutrition for slowing digestive systems.
Best Candidates for Ancient Grain Formulas
Ancient grain dog food is ideal for:
Dogs Without Grain Sensitivities: The vast majority of dogs (approximately 90%) have no grain allergies or sensitivities. For these dogs, ancient grains provide superior nutrition compared to grain-free alternatives.
At-Risk Breeds for DCM: Golden Retrievers, Cocker Spaniels, Doberman Pinschers, Irish Wolfhounds, Great Danes, Boxers, and Newfoundlands benefit from the heart-protective nutrient profile in ancient grain formulas.
Senior Dogs: Older dogs with slowing metabolisms and sensitive digestive systems thrive on the gentle fiber and balanced energy from ancient grains. The anti-inflammatory properties of grains like sorghum also support aging joints.
Moderately Active Dogs: Weekend warriors and family pets with moderate exercise needs (30-60 minutes daily) do well on ancient grain formulas. The balanced protein-to-carb ratio provides sufficient energy without excessive calories.
Budget-Conscious Quality Seekers: Ancient grain formulas often cost less than premium grain-free options while delivering equal or superior nutrition—making them excellent choices for multi-dog households seeking quality on a budget.
Side-by-Side Comparison: Grain-Free vs Ancient Grains
To help you make an informed decision, here's a comprehensive comparison of grain-free and ancient grain dog food options:
| Factor | Grain-Free | Ancient Grains |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Dogs with confirmed grain allergies, high-protein needs, certain digestive sensitivities | Most dogs, breeds at DCM risk, senior dogs, budget-conscious quality nutrition |
| Typical Protein Content | 30-40% (meat-first formulas) | 22-28% (balanced with grain nutrients) |
| Carbohydrate Sources | Sweet potatoes, peas, lentils, chickpeas, tapioca, white potatoes | Quinoa, millet, barley, oats, sorghum, amaranth |
| Fiber Content | 2-4% (varies widely by formula) | 3-6% (consistent, diverse fiber types) |
| Digestibility | Variable—depends on legume content and processing; some dogs thrive, others struggle | Generally excellent due to gentle fiber matrix and balanced formulation |
| Heart Health Considerations | Monitor for DCM risk factors; choose formulas with limited peas/lentils and added taurine | Vet-recommended for at-risk breeds; supports cardiovascular function naturally |
| Energy Delivery | Quick energy from simple carbs; may spike blood sugar in sensitive dogs | Slow-release energy from complex carbs; stable blood glucose |
| Price Point | $$$ - $$$$ (typically premium pricing, $3.50-$6.00/lb) | $$ - $$$ (mid to premium range, $2.50-$4.50/lb) |
| Allergen Considerations | Eliminates grain allergies; may have legume/potato sensitivities in some dogs | Not suitable for dogs with confirmed grain allergies |
| Ingredient Transparency | Variable—some brands excellent, others use pea protein isolates and fillers | Generally high—ancient grains appear by name on ingredient panels |
| Veterinary Consensus | Safe when properly formulated; requires careful formula selection | Widely recommended as balanced, safe option for most dogs |
The Bottom Line: Neither option is universally "better"—the right choice depends entirely on your individual dog's health needs, activity level, breed risk factors, and sensitivities.
How to Choose the Right Option for Your Dog
Still unsure whether grain-free or ancient grains is the best choice for your furry companion? Use these guidelines to make a confident decision.
Signs Your Dog May Need Grain-Free
Consider grain-free formulas if your dog experiences:
Confirmed Grain Allergy: Your veterinarian has conducted an elimination diet or allergy testing confirming sensitivity to specific grains. Symptoms typically include:
-
Chronic itching, especially around paws, ears, and belly
-
Recurrent hot spots or skin infections
-
Persistent ear infections
-
Hair loss or dull, brittle coat
-
Excessive licking or scratching
Chronic Digestive Upset: After ruling out parasites, inflammatory bowel disease, pancreatitis, and other medical conditions, your dog continues experiencing:
-
Soft stools or diarrhea (despite diet consistency)
-
Excessive gas or bloating
-
Vomiting undigested food
-
Poor appetite or food avoidance
Weight Management Challenges: Despite appropriate portions and exercise, your dog struggles to maintain a healthy weight on grain-inclusive formulas. Some dogs metabolize proteins more efficiently than carbohydrates, making high-protein grain-free formulas beneficial for weight control.
High Activity Requirements: Working dogs (search and rescue, her
continue
ding, police K9s, agility competitors, hunting dogs) require significantly more calories and often perform better on the higher protein density of grain-free formulas (30-40% protein vs. 22-28% in grain-inclusive foods).
Important Note: Never switch to grain-free based on trends or marketing alone. If your dog is thriving on their current food, there's no reason to change. Work with your veterinarian to identify legitimate medical reasons before making the switch.
Signs Ancient Grains May Be Better
Ancient grain formulas are likely the better choice if:
No Food Sensitivities Present: Your dog has never shown signs of food allergies, grain intolerances, or digestive issues. Why exclude grains if they're not causing problems? Ancient grains provide valuable nutrition that grain-free alternatives can't match.
At-Risk Breed for DCM: If your dog is a Golden Retriever, Cocker Spaniel, Doberman Pinscher, Irish Wolfhound, Great Dane, Boxer, or Newfoundland—breeds showing elevated DCM risk on certain grain-free diets—ancient grain formulas offer peace of mind with heart-protective nutrients.
Senior Dog with Changing Needs: Older dogs often develop more sensitive digestive systems as they age. The gentle fiber in ancient grains supports regularity, while the balanced energy prevents weight gain in less-active seniors. The anti-inflammatory compounds in grains like sorghum also support aging joints.
Digestive Sensitivity on Grain-Free: Some dogs develop soft stools, gas, or bloating on legume-heavy grain-free formulas. If your dog struggled with pea- or lentil-based foods, ancient grains often resolve these issues while still providing quality nutrition.
Budget Considerations: Premium ancient grain formulas typically cost $2.50-$4.50 per pound compared to $3.50-$6.00 per pound for grain-free options. For multi-dog households, this difference adds up while still delivering excellent nutrition.
The Talis-Us Recommendation: A Veterinary Partnership Approach
At Talis-us, we believe the best food choice starts with professional guidance:
1. Consult Your Veterinarian: Before switching foods, discuss your dog's health history, breed-specific risks, current body condition, and any symptoms you've noticed. Your vet can recommend appropriate allergy testing if sensitivities are suspected.
2. Consider an Elimination Diet: If food allergies are suspected but not confirmed, your vet may recommend an 8-12 week elimination diet using a novel protein source (like venison, duck, or kangaroo) with limited ingredients. This gold-standard approach identifies true food allergies versus other health issues.
3. Transition Gradually: Abrupt food changes cause digestive upset regardless of food quality. Follow this 7-10 day transition schedule:
- Days 1-3: 75% current food, 25% new food
- Days 4-6: 50% current food, 50% new food
- Days 7-9: 25% current food, 75% new food
- Day 10+: 100% new food
4. Monitor These Key Indicators:
- Stool Quality: Firm, well-formed stools (not hard or loose)
- Energy Levels: Consistent activity and enthusiasm
- Coat Condition: Shiny, soft coat without excessive shedding
- Body Condition: Maintaining healthy weight with visible waist
- Appetite: Eager eating without food avoidance
5. Look for Talis-Us Quality Badges: When browsing our natural dog food collection, filter by:
- "Vet-Recommended": Brands consistently endorsed by veterinary nutritionists
- "Limited-Ingredient": Clean formulas ideal for sensitive dogs
- "Single-Protein": Clear protein sources for allergy management
- "Talis Curated": Products meeting our highest quality standards across all categories
6. Don't Be Afraid to Adjust: Every dog is unique. What works for one Golden Retriever may not work for another. If your dog isn't thriving after 4-6 weeks on a new food (digestive issues persist, coat quality declines, energy drops), revisit the decision with your vet.
Top Natural Dog Food Picks from Talis-Us
Ready to explore premium natural dog food options? Here are our expert-curated favorites across both categories, each selected for ingredient quality, manufacturing standards, and proven results.
Grain-Free Favorites
1. Premium Limited-Ingredient Turkey & Sweet Potato Formula
Ideal for: Dogs with grain sensitivities, food allergies, or sensitive stomachs
This single-protein formula features responsibly sourced turkey as the sole animal protein, eliminating common allergens like chicken, beef, and fish. Sweet potatoes provide gentle, low-glycemic carbohydrates without peas or lentils—addressing DCM concerns.
Key Features:
-
32% protein from turkey meat and turkey meal
-
Pea-free, lentil-free formula
-
Added taurine for heart health support
-
Omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids for skin and coat
-
Probiotics for digestive health
Talis-Us Badges: Limited-Ingredient, Single-Protein, Vet-Recommended
Best For: Dogs with diagnosed food allergies, chronic digestive issues, or breeds at moderate DCM risk who need grain-free nutrition.
2. High-Protein Wild-Caught Salmon Formula
Ideal for: Active dogs, skin health support, omega-rich nutrition
Wild-caught salmon delivers 35% protein along with exceptional omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) that support cognitive function, joint health, and lustrous coat shine. Tapioca and sweet potatoes provide energy without legumes.
Key Features:
-
35% protein from wild-caught salmon
-
High omega-3 content (minimum 1.2%)
-
Limited ingredients (just 8 primary components)
-
No peas, lentils, or white potatoes
-
Rich in natural astaxanthin for antioxidant support
Talis-Us Badges: Single-Protein, Limited-Ingredient
Best For: Working dogs, sporting breeds, dogs with dry skin or dull coats, and salmon-loving picky eaters.
3. Grass-Fed Bison & Root Vegetable Recipe
Ideal for: Novel protein needs, dogs with common protein allergies
For dogs reactive to chicken, beef, and lamb, bison provides a nutritious novel protein alternative. This formula combines grass-fed bison with a thoughtful blend of sweet potatoes, butternut squash, and pumpkin—no peas or lentils.
Key Features:
-
30% protein from grass-fed bison
-
Novel protein ideal for elimination diets
-
Digestive enzymes and probiotics
-
Glucosamine and chondroitin for joint support
-
Legume-free carbohydrate sources
Talis-Us Badges: Limited-Ingredient, Single-Protein
Best For: Dogs with chicken or beef allergies, large breeds needing joint support, dogs requiring novel protein sources.
Ancient Grain Champions
4. Quinoa & Grass-Fed Lamb Recipe
Ideal for: All life stages, heart health, Golden Retrievers and at-risk breeds
This veterinarian-recommended formula combines nutrient-rich quinoa with grass-fed lamb for complete nutrition. Specifically formulated with taurine, L-carnitine, and amino acids that support cardiovascular function in breeds prone to DCM.
Key Features:
-
26% protein from grass-fed lamb
-
Quinoa, millet, and oats for diverse grain nutrition
-
Added taurine and L-carnitine for heart health
-
Omega-rich for coat shine
-
No peas, lentils, or legume proteins
Talis-Us Badges: Vet-Recommended, Ancient Grains, Heart Health Support
Best For: Golden Retrievers, Cocker Spaniels, Dobermans, and other at-risk breeds; adult dogs of all sizes; health-conscious pet parents.
5. Millet & Free-Range Chicken Formula
Ideal for: Senior dogs, gentle digestion, budget-conscious quality
This gentle formula features easily digestible millet paired with free-range chicken. The balanced fiber content (4.5%) supports regularity in older dogs, while glucosamine and chondroitin ease aging joints.
Key Features:
-
24% protein from free-range chicken
-
Millet and sorghum for gentle digestion
-
Elevated glucosamine (600 mg/kg minimum)
-
Prebiotic fiber for gut health
-
Lower fat content (12%) ideal for less-active seniors
Talis-Us Badges: Ancient Grains, Senior-Friendly, Vet-Recommended
Best For: Dogs 7+ years old, less active dogs, those with sensitive stomachs, multi-dog households seeking quality on a budget.
6. Multi-Grain Salmon & Ancient Grain Blend
Ideal for: Skin health, allergies to poultry, omega-rich nutrition with grains
For dogs needing grain-inclusive nutrition but sensitive to chicken or beef, this salmon-based formula delivers. A diverse ancient grain blend (quinoa, amaranth, barley, and oats) provides complete nutrition with exceptional omega-3 content.
Key Features:
-
28% protein from wild-caught salmon
-
Four ancient grains for diverse nutrients
-
Exceptional omega-3 content (1.4% minimum)
-
Added taurine and L-carnitine
-
Probiotics and digestive enzymes
Talis-Us Badges: Ancient Grains, Single-Protein, Skin & Coat Support
Best For: Dogs with poultry sensitivities, dry skin or allergies, breeds prone to heart issues who need grain-inclusive nutrition.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is grain-free dog food bad for my dog's heart?
The relationship between grain-free diets and heart disease is nuanced. Research suggests that grain-free diets aren't inherently dangerous—rather, specific formulation factors may contribute to diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in susceptible dogs.
The key risk factors include:
-
Heavy reliance on peas, lentils, and legume derivatives (pea protein, pea starch)
-
Potatoes as a primary carbohydrate source
-
Insufficient taurine, L-carnitine, or amino acid precursors
-
Feeding duration (multiple years on the same formula)
-
Breed predisposition (Golden Retrievers, Cocker Spaniels, Dobermans)
Grain-free is safe when: The formula uses sweet potatoes or tapioca (not peas/lentils) as primary carbs, includes taurine supplementation, comes from a reputable manufacturer with feeding trials, and your dog isn't a high-risk breed.
If your dog is an at-risk breed or you're concerned about DCM, consult your veterinarian. They may recommend an echocardiogram as a baseline and periodic taurine level testing. Many vets now recommend ancient grain formulas as a safer alternative that provides balanced nutrition without DCM concerns.
Are ancient grains the same as whole grains?
Ancient grains are a specific subset of whole grains. The key difference lies in their agricultural history:
Ancient Grains: Grain varieties that have remained largely unchanged for thousands of years, with minimal modern breeding or genetic modification. Examples: quinoa, amaranth, millet, sorghum, spelled, teff. These retain their original nutrient density and genetic diversity.
Modern Whole Grains: Grains that have been selectively bred over recent decades for agricultural convenience (higher yields, pest resistance, uniform growing). Examples: modern wheat, hybrid corn, cultivated rice. While still "whole" (containing bran, germ, and endosperm), they may have different nutrient profiles than their ancient ancestors.
Nutritionally: Ancient grains often provide more diverse micronutrients, antioxidants, and amino acid profiles than their modern counterparts. They're also less likely to have been genetically modified. However, modern whole grains like brown rice and oats are still nutritious options—the "ancient" designation simply indicates minimal agricultural manipulation.
In premium dog food, ancient grains offer marketing transparency (you know exactly what grain variety you're feeding) and potentially superior nutritional diversity compared to generic "grain" or "cereal" listings.
Can I mix grain-free and grain-inclusive foods?
Rotation feeding—alternating between different protein sources and formulations—is a strategy some veterinarians recommend, while others advise consistency. The answer depends on your dog's individual needs.
Potential Benefits of Rotation:
-
Exposes dogs to diverse nutrients from different ingredients
-
Reduces risk of developing sensitivities through constant exposure to one protein
-
May address the "monotonous diet" theory related to DCM (though not scientifically proven)
-
Provides dietary variety some dogs enjoy
Potential Drawbacks:
-
Can cause digestive upset in sensitive dogs
-
Makes allergy identification difficult if issues arise
-
Complicates portion control and calorie management
-
Some dogs do better with consistency
If you choose to rotate: Transition gradually over 7-10 days between each formula. Rotate by protein source (turkey, salmon, lamb) rather than just grain status. Monitor stool quality and energy levels. Keep a food journal noting which formulas your dog tolerates best.
At Talis-us, we recommend: For healthy dogs without sensitivities, rotating between 2-3 high-quality formulas every 2-3 months can provide nutritional variety. For dogs with allergies, digestive issues, or medical conditions, consistency with one formula is usually better. Always consult your veterinarian before implementing rotation feeding.
How do I know if my dog has a grain allergy?
True grain allergies in dogs are relatively uncommon but do occur. Here's how to identify them:
Common Symptoms of Grain Allergy:
-
Skin Issues: Chronic itching (especially paws, ears, belly), recurrent hot spots, hives, excessive licking, hair loss, chronic skin infections
-
Ear Problems: Frequent ear infections, head shaking, ear discharge, red or inflamed ear canals
-
Digestive Issues: Chronic diarrhea, vomiting, gas, poor stool quality (though this can indicate intolerance rather than true allergy)
-
Respiratory Signs: Less common, but can include coughing or wheezing
Diagnosis Process:
-
Veterinary Exam: Rule out other causes (parasites, environmental allergies, yeast infections, hormonal imbalances)
-
Elimination Diet: The gold standard. Feed a novel protein + carb source (like venison + sweet potato) for 8-12 weeks with NO other foods, treats, or table scraps
-
Challenge Phase: Reintroduce grains one at a time. If symptoms return within 2 weeks, you've identified the culprit
-
Allergy Testing: Blood tests or intradermal testing can identify potential allergens but are less reliable than elimination diets for food allergies
Important Distinction: Food intolerance (digestive upset) is different from true allergy (immune system response). Intolerance may resolve with different grain types or processing methods, while true allergy requires complete avoidance.
If grain allergy is confirmed: Switch to a high-quality grain-free formula from our Limited-Ingredient collection, ensure all treats are grain-free, and work with your vet on long-term management.
What's better: organic dog food or natural dog food?
Both terms indicate quality, but they have distinct meanings regulated by different authorities:
Natural Dog Food (AAFCO Definition):
-
Ingredients derived from plant, animal, or mined sources
-
No chemically synthesized ingredients (except vitamins/minerals)
-
Minimal processing
-
No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives
Organic Dog Food (USDA Organic Certification):
-
All ingredients (or 95%+) must be USDA certified organic
-
No synthetic pesticides, fertilizers, or GMOs
-
Animals raised without antibiotics or growth hormones
-
Processed without irradiation or artificial additives
-
Requires annual certification and farm inspections
Which is Better?
Choose Organic If: You prioritize environmental sustainability, want guaranteed no-pesticide exposure, prefer supporting organic farming practices, and budget allows (organic typically costs 30-50% more).
Choose Natural (Non-Organic) If: You want high-quality ingredients without the organic price premium, your priority is ingredient sourcing and manufacturing standards over farming practices, or organic options are limited for your dog's specific dietary needs.
The Bottom Line: Both can be excellent choices. At Talis-us, we curate both natural and organic options. Many of our top-rated natural foods source organic ingredients but don't carry official USDA certification due to cost constraints on smaller manufacturers. Focus on ingredient quality, manufacturing standards, and your dog's individual response rather than labels alone.
